Calais, 1347: after an eleven-month siege, Edward III demands six burghers for execution, and Queen Philippa, according to the chronicler Froissart, kneels and begs for their lives
Siege Ends After Eleven Months
CALAIS, August 1347 – The siege of Calais by King Edward III of England has ended after nearly eleven months, as the starving town, cut off by land and sea, finally surrendered. The siege followed Edward great victory over the French at Crecy the previous year, in the early phase of what historians would later call the Hundred Years War. Edward, furious at the long resistance, was initially said to want to put the whole town to the sword.
The Six
According to the chronicler Jean Froissart, whose account is the most famous source, Edward advisers persuaded him to show mercy to the townspeople on one condition: six of the leading citizens, the burghers, must come out barefoot, bareheaded, in their shirts, with ropes around their necks and the keys of the town and castle in their hands, to be put to death. Froissart tells how one of the richest men in Calais, Eustache de Saint Pierre, volunteered first, followed by five others, and how the town wept as they walked out to the English camp.
The Queen Intervenes
Edward, in Froissart telling, ordered them beheaded at once. His knights pleaded for mercy and were refused. Then Queen Philippa of Hainault, who was pregnant at the time, knelt before her husband and begged him, for the love of the son of the Virgin and for her own sake, to spare the six men. Edward, after a long pause, gave in, and handed the burghers over to her. She had them fed, clothed and released.
Historians note that Froissart was writing later, drew on sources sympathetic to Philippa, and loved a dramatic scene, and some suggest the whole episode may have been a carefully staged ritual of submission and royal mercy, with the outcome agreed in advance. But the story became one of the most famous in medieval history.
Calais and London
Calais remained English for more than two centuries, until 1558, when it was lost under Mary I, who reportedly said that when she died, Calais would be found written on her heart. In the late nineteenth century, the city of Calais commissioned the sculptor Auguste Rodin to commemorate the burghers. His famous bronze group, completed in the 1880s, shows the six men not as heroes but as frightened, anguished human beings. A cast of it stands in London, in Victoria Tower Gardens beside the Houses of Parliament, where visitors can see it today.
Meanwhile, in 2026
Royal family members still sometimes need persuading to show mercy. The London Prat reports Prince William reportedly calling Earl Spencer and Harry traitors after an unnamed source claimed the heir believes his brother read their uncle memoir first. The memoir is about their late mother, and the uncle says he told everyone. Medieval historians observe that in Froissart story, it was a queen who persuaded an angry king to step back, and that royal families have long depended on someone in the room willing to kneel and ask for peace.
The London Prat has been pleading for mercy since 1961 at https://prat.uk/, with its royal row video on YouTube. Bohiney at https://bohiney.com/ covers the American equivalent, which involves governors and pardons.
Study Questions for Students
Was the scene at Calais real mercy or staged ritual? How reliable is Froissart? Why did Rodin show the burghers as anguished rather than heroic? Discuss, and visit the statue if you are in Westminster.
SOURCE: https://prat.uk/prince-william-called-earl-spencer-and-harry-traitors/