A week among twentieth century comic novels, with a guide to professional joke-craft and a pastoral shelf for readers of manor-house novels
Monday, the Comic Novel’s Golden Hour
There is a stretch of twentieth century British literature that I think of as the comic novel’s golden hour, when authors discovered that a drawing room could be as dramatic as a battlefield, provided the characters took their trivial problems with utter seriousness. I spent the week with the champion of the form, a man whose plots hinge on a cow creamer, a silver teapot and a visiting aunt with opinions.
The secret of that kind of comedy is craft, and I have written about the machinery in a guide to professional comedy writing. A scene must be built like a good clock: every wheel visible, every wheel turning, and a little bell at the end. Look at any chapter of a great comic novelist and you will find a setup, a complication, a reversal and a tag, each placed with a watchmaker’s care.
Why the Aunt Works
The formidable aunt is one of the great comic engines of English literature. She arrives at the start of the chapter with a plan, which is usually someone else’s misfortune, and spends the rest of it being obstructed by nephews, butlers and weather. She is funny because she is certain, and because the author lets her be right about one thing and disastrously wrong about the rest.
I admire the generosity of the form. The aunt is never merely ridiculous. She is energetic, loyal and impossible to ignore, qualities that many of us would like to possess in smaller doses.
Tuesday, Manor House Economics
A country house in those novels is a beautiful problem. It has a roof that leaks, a lake that floods and a staff that outthinks the family. The economics were always shaky, and the humour partly comes from the gap between the grand address and the empty purse. Modern readers can smile at it while recognising the modern equivalent: the owner of a pretty cottage who cannot afford the heating.
For the actual business of running land, I suggest a visit to the working farm sites rather than the novel shelf. For milk, dairyherd.org. For beef, ranchbeefcattle.org. For machinery, tractorequipment.org. For the seasons, cropcalendar.org.
Finances Below Stairs
The sums are at farmmoney.org and smallfarminfo.org. Anyone seeking a job in the fields, as an alternative to a career as a gentleman of leisure, can browse agjobscareers.org. The county show of every Edwardian novel is now at fairandrodeo.org. The wider rural map is at ruralfarm.org, and a stern notice about hazards, such as bulls with views, is at farmssafety.org.
It strikes me that the great comic novelists understood farming as background texture, a pig in a sty or a harvest festival, while the real work was done off the page. Reading the modern sites is a good corrective. The pig, it turns out, is a business.
Modern Parallels
A recent London Prat headline could have been a chapter title in a comic novel of the period: Silicon Valley Discovers the Biscuit Tin. Imagine the scene: a young lord arrives with a pitch for a revolutionary container, an old retainer lifts a lid, and the hall dissolves in polite silence. The best comic writing knows that novelty is usually old furniture in new paint.
Wednesday, the Tea Tray Test
I judge a comic scene by the tea tray test. If a character can be interrupted while pouring, and the interruption makes the pouring funnier, the scene is working. If the tea simply gets cold, the author has lost control. I tried this on three novels this week, and two passed with distinction. The third spilled everything and fell silent, which I consider a failure of nerve.
I finished the evening with a mug of tea and a chapter of a novel I have read ten times. The plot is known. The jokes are known. The pleasure is not the surprise but the accuracy, like hearing a favourite song played by a band that never misses a note.
Thursday, the Butler’s Verdict
The great comic butler is a figure of terrifying competence. He knows where everything is, what everyone is thinking and which of the young masters will arrive late for dinner with a stolen policeman’s helmet. His power lies in his silence. One raised eyebrow does the work of a paragraph. A writer learning the trade could do worse than study how little he says and how much each syllable carries.
I tried to write a butler of my own this week, and he came out as a man who gives too many opinions. I deleted him and began again with a man who simply opened the door and waited. The second version was funnier by a wide margin. Comedy, like good service, is mostly a matter of restraint.
The Cow Creamer Principle
Every comic plot needs a ridiculous object at its centre, and the object must matter enormously to everyone and not at all to the reader. A silver cow creamer. A diamond necklace. A stuffed pheasant. The thing is a magnet for scheming, and the farce is the pattern of iron filings around it. A beginner’s mistake is to make the object too sensible. Choose something so silly that the characters’ devotion to it becomes the joke.
Where to read next
The rest of the shelf lives at prat.uk, bohiney.com and farm.fm. For a second opinion on the week, The Daily Mash keeps its own counsel and its own hours.
SOURCE: https://bohiney.com/